- GameSpy.com - [69/100] By Tamara "Curacao" Schembri. "The puzzles in Gilbert Goodmate are logical and fun, probably the best individual aspect of the game."
- GilbertGoodmate.com - Official homepage for "Gilbert Goodmate and the Mushroom of Phungoria". Site has screenshots, the storyline, and information about the characters in the game.
- Just Adventure Review - Rated C- by Randy Sluganski. "Gilbert Goodmate and the Mushroom of Phungoria is a noble, but ultimately failed, attempt to recapture the magic of LucasArts circa 1995."
Media publications
- Adventure Gamers Review - Rated 3/5. "An enjoyable enough adventure. Traditionalists will appreciate the LEC style, but it is far from flawless." By Joonas Linkola (Published 2002.09.30)
- GameZone.com - [7.6/10] Review by Da Bomb Mom. "Of all the games I have played in the past year or so this one has to be the simplest in graphics, gameplay and storyline and I have to say that it is also one of the most relaxing." Screenshots. (Published 2001.06.05)
- Quandary Preview - "If you are an aficionado of the 'old fashioned', tastefully humorous Quest/Adventure (as I am), you will welcome Gilbert Goodmate and the Mushroom of Phungoria as a delightful reminder of past glories and look forward immensely to its, hopefully imminent, release." By Len Green. (Published 2001.03.00)